The Cycle of Fear, Greed, and Shrinking Returns

Aug 2, 2023

Cartoon image of a person buying a new car. The interaction says: "I'm looking for a new car." "Oh, you're in luck. We just marked them up 30%" "Oh, that's fantastic. I'll take three!" The caption reads "This would be ludicrous when it comes to buying a car, but it's precisely how we behave sometimes when we let our emotions guide our investment decisions."

$100 is on the table, and you have a choice.

You can choose to receive $50 or flip a coin. If you choose the coin toss and get heads, you get $100. If it’s tails, you get nothing.

What do you do?

If you’re like most folks, you’re probably going to take the $50. It’s a sure thing.

Now, what if this were a game of losses?

What if you stood to lose $50 out of the gate?

And what if the coin toss meant losing $100 with heads or losing nothing with tails?

What would you do then?

Here, most folks choose to flip the coin.

And even though they’re making a different decision — flipping the coin and taking the risk, instead of going with the known option — their reasoning hasn’t really changed. In both cases, the choice is largely based on fear, the fear of losses.1

That fear is natural.2

So is a related emotion, greed.3

In fact, fear and greed are behind a lot of our financial choices and, often, not the best ones.4

It doesn’t matter if the markets are bullish or bearish…greed and fear can easily creep in and disrupt our ability to make sound, long-term decisions.

That’s how we lose big — and how we get in the cycle of buy high, sell low, and lose BIG.5

The illustration below basically sums up the mistakes we make with our money over and over.

A basic curved line diagram that goes upward, downward, and then upward again. At the highest point of the line a caption states "GREED/BUY" with an arrow pointing to the top. The lowest point of the graph has a caption stating "FEAR/SELL" and an arrow pointing to that spot on the line.

Let’s take a look at the greed/fear cycle by walking through some key moments when mass fear and greed put markets and investors in a tailspin.

How $25 Trillion+ Has Been Lost to Greed & Fear in 35 Years

A newspaper with an image of an oil rig on the front.

1987 Stock Market Crash (Black Monday)

When: Monday, Oct. 19, 1987

Why: PANIC! Wall Street melted down, giving into fear in response to major world events. A U.S. attack on an Iranian oil platform caused a massive panic, with fear driving many to sell ASAP. Markets crashed soon after.6

The Losses: The Dow dropped ~22.6%, falling 508 points. That’s roughly the same as a 7,000-point freefall in today’s markets.7

A newspaper with a laptop with the words "404 ERROR"

Dotcom Bubble

When: ~1995 to ~2002, with a peak on March 10, 2000, and a crash on Oct. 4, 2002

Why: Extreme optimism in the early Internet age sparked overconfidence, widespread speculation, and overvaluations. Folks gave into GREED, rushing to invest in companies and concepts before they had proven models or finished products. Some didn’t even have business plans. That lasted for years until the bubble burst in late 2002, as investment dollars dried up and many tech companies went under. When the bubble burst, greed turned into FEAR as investors rushed to get out.8

The Losses: The Nasdaq fell nearly 77%, dropping from roughly 5,132.52 (in March 2000) to 1,139.90 by Oct. 2002. Tech companies that didn’t go under saw their values decline by as much as 80%.8 All said and done, the burst of the dotcom bubble resulted in losses of around $5 trillion.9

A newspaper with an image of the remnants of an old building.

2008 Financial Crisis (The Great Recession)

When: 2007 to 2009

Why: Cheap credit and new banking laws ushered in a new era of GREED, along with a sharp rise in subprime mortgages. That created a new “housing bubble” that ballooned as banks, insurance companies, and others merged into “too-big-to-fail” entities. The bubble burst, however, with greed once again turning into fear, as many rushed to get out fast, losing BIG in the process. When interest rates rose, borrowers defaulted and housing prices plummeted. That set off a cycle of FEAR and painful losses for hedge funds, lenders, and many others.10

The Losses: U.S. households lost ~26% of their net worth or roughly $17 trillion in inflation-adjusted terms. Roughly 7.5 million jobs were lost in a matter of two years. A decade after this crisis, experts say the economy shrunk by ~7%, translating to about $70,000 per American.10

A newspaper with an image of a person falling into a hole.

2010 Flash Crash

When: May 6, 2010

Why: The market was highly volatile, starting low and tumbling with Greek market fluctuations and elections in the UK. The market took a nosedive, however, with a massive automatic sell order.11 That caused PANIC and a near-contagious level of fear, with rumors of cyberattacks rampant. By the end of the day, the markets recovered about half of the total value lost.12

The Losses: About $1 trillion in market value disappeared in the 2010 Flash Crash.11 During the height of the Flash Crash, approximately $56 billion traded hands in merely 20 minutes.12

A newspaper with a coin with the Bitcoin logo, ripped in half.

Cryptocurrency Bubble & Bust

When: ~2020 to ~2022

Why: Crypto has been through a couple of bubbles and busts. The most recent one happened during the pandemic, with GREED gripping many folks out of work and bored at home. That’s when optimism and crypto GREED was high, with many rushing to buy the newest blockchain assets available, including nonfungible tokens (NFTs). Some of these assets appreciated by 20 to 40 times their original value, stoking investor GREED. But it didn’t last. Rising interest rates, inflation, and world events, like the war in Ukraine, soon turned that greed into fear. That fear led into a crypto crash in late 2022, with incredible losses to follow. Once again, greed, fear, and panic caused sharp losses for many.13

The Losses: An estimated $2 trillion was lost so far in the most recent crypto crash. Most of that disappeared in about 6 months.13

What if…you ignored the cycle of fear and greed?

A newspaper with an image of bags, and bags surrounding the newspaper.

The Lump Sum Investment

Let’s look at a simple example: Someone invests a lump sum of $10,000 in the S&P 500 in January 1987. Assuming an average annual return of 10.11% over the next 35 years, that $10,000 lump sum would have grown to about $320,694 by the end of 2022.14

That’s a total return of over 3,100% on the initial $10,000 investment.14

Takeaway: This shows the significant compound growth possible from a lump sum investment left untouched for decades. Of course, staying invested through many ups and downs requires patience and discipline. But the long-term rewards can be substantial with a buy-and-hold approach.

An image of a newspaper with a cartoon turtle crossing a finish line.

The Power of Consistency

Consider the following investment approach: Investing $500 per month in the S&P 500 from 1987 through 2022.

That’s a total investment of $210,000 over 35 years.

Assuming an average annual return of 10.11%, those monthly $500 contributions would have grown to around $1.7 million by the end of 2022.15

That’s a cumulative return of over 700% on the total $210,000 invested over decades.15

Takeaway: This example illustrates the power of consistent investing over long time periods. By sticking to a regular contribution plan, one can potentially build substantial wealth through compounding growth, even if investing relatively small amounts. The key is to stay disciplined and keep investing through ups and downs.

Whether or not you’ve had a front seat to market booms or busts, the reality is any of us can get anxious, afraid, or even greedy with sudden shocks and surprises in the markets.

FINANCIAL LESSON:

How to Nurture Better Financial Instincts & Mute the Pull of Greed & Fear

Were you surprised to see the losses caused by greed and fear?

What do you think you’ve lost or avoided losing in these bubbles, busts, and crises?

If you could go back in time and handle any of them differently, would you?

Whether or not you’ve had a front seat to market booms or busts, the reality is any of us can get anxious, afraid, or even greedy with sudden shocks and surprises in the markets.16

That’s true for even the smartest folks who know the most about finance.

After all, we have to deal with some uncertainty when we’re in the markets.

No one can predict what’s going to happen next, and that can be a tipping point for fear and greed, especially in turbulent times.

With that fear and greed, we tend to be more impulsive. We may even panic and rush to act because we’re afraid of missing out (FOMO, anyone?).

That’s when we can be more vulnerable to poor choices and the losses that we’re so desperate to avoid, like selling low and buying high.

And that can set off a cycle of loss that keeps our long-term goals out of reach.17

But it doesn’t have to.

The more we know about fear, greed, loss, and our financial choices, the better.

That’s how we can get our emotions and instincts in check to make better financial decisions, regardless of what the markets are doing.

Of course, that’s not always easy to remember in the moment.

That’s why we shouldn’t jump on any bandwagons or dive into big financial choices without thinking them through.

Instead, we can take some simple steps to avoid the fear/greed cycle and do the following:

  1. Set some long-term financial goals.
  2. Get some distance and avoid checking your portfolio day to day.
  3. Take your time and think things through.

It’s prudent to check in with the folks we trust, especially when it’s time to make major money moves.

Sources

Brad Tedrick is an LPL Registered Principal with, and securities offered through LPL Financial, Member FINRA/SIPC. Investment advice offered through Vantedge Wealth Management, a registered investment advisor and separate entity from LPL Financial. CA Insurance License #0B47923. Content in this material is for general information only and not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any individual. All performance referenced is historical and is no guarantee of future results. All indices are unmanaged and may not be invested into directly. No strategy assures success or protects against loss. Investing involves risk including loss of principal.

Risk Disclosure: Investing involves risk including the potential loss of principal. No investment strategy can guarantee a profit or protect against loss in periods of declining values. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

This material is for information purposes only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security. The content is developed from sources believed to be providing accurate information; no warranty, expressed or implied, is made regarding accuracy, adequacy, completeness, legality, reliability, or usefulness of any information. Consult your financial professional before making any investment decision. For illustrative use only.

How Earnings Can Guide Investors in Difficult Markets

How Earnings Can Guide Investors in Difficult Markets

With markets nervous about stubborn inflation, a gradually slowing labor market, and the timing of the first Fed rate cut, investors are more focused on this corporate earnings season than usual. This is because while the economy has avoided a “hard landing” corporate...

Why Cash Is Not a Long-Term Investment

Why Cash Is Not a Long-Term Investment

In times of market uncertainty, investors often seek the safety of cash. This has been true over the past several years as markets have swung due to the pandemic, geopolitical events, Fed rate hikes, inflation, gridlock in Washington, technology trends, and more. More...

How the Costs and Benefits of College Affect Financial Plans

How the Costs and Benefits of College Affect Financial Plans

For many households, college decisions are a cause for celebration. However, college also represents one of the largest expenses and sources of financial stress in our lives, on par with retirement or buying a home. These feelings are only worsened by the current...

More Information You Might Like

Holistic Wealth Management

Holistic Wealth Management is an integrated and coordinated approach to all areas of Wealth Management.  At Vantedge Wealth, our advisors create a collaborative environment with clients to find common sense, easy-to-comprehend approaches to their personal finances.